Drawing The Right Conclusions From The Brady-Mahomes Superbowl Matchup

Start by understanding it was not a Brady-Mahomes matchup. Those two were never on the field at the same time. The heart of yesterday’s game was a matchup of Tom Brady and the Bucs’ offensive team against the Chiefs’ defense and a completely separate matchup of Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs’ offensive team against the Bucs’ defense. As you know, the Bucs won both.

Quick quiz. How many passes did Brady complete?

None.

21 of his 29 passes were caught by his teammates, none by him. And, he doesn’t even get to throw the ball without the offensive line giving him time.

With that in mind, let me suggest the Bucs won because of 1) Belief, 2) Strategy, 3) Tactics, 4) Hard work, 5) Discipline.

1) Belief. Tampa Bay’s owners, GM, coaches, quarterback, and team believed in themselves. This is straight out of Virgil, “They can because they think they can.” Brady, Gronk, Brown, and Fournette didn’t go to Tampa to turn the team around, have a winning season, or win the conference. Their standard was to win the Superbowl. As Brady put it at the end of the game, “I think we knew this was going to happen. Didn’t we?”

2) Strategy is about the creation and allocation of resources to the right place in the right way at the right time over time. The Bucs owner, GM and head coach didn’t just bring in Brady. They brought in the right coaches, coordinators, staff, receivers, runners, offensive line, and defense.

3) Tactics are about the deployment of forces in the battle. The Bucs’ array of runs, screens and play-action on offense produced 31 points. On defense, the Bucs’ almost complete neutering of Tyreek Hill and exploitation of the Chiefs’ two back-up tackles led to constant pressure on Mahomes and limiting the Chiefs to three field goals and nine points.

4) Hard Work. Lombardi put it best, “The will to win is not nearly so important as the will to prepare to win.” No team gets to the Superbowl without hard work. The teams that win, work that much harder. And Brady’s regime is legendary. The work he puts to perform at his best physically and mentally is in a different league. Brady and his teams win partly because they work harder than anyone else – all the time.

5) Discipline. The Bucs beat the Chiefs fair and square. On top of that, the Chiefs beat themselves. Their discipline broke first. They had 95 yards in penalties in the first half, some of which made material differences. The Bucs kept their discipline when it mattered.

Implications for you

Belief

Great leaders bring out others self-confidence. This is true at every level from owners to CEOs to executives to Sam Walker’s Captain Class tactical leaders. Cut through the consultant-speak of missions, visions, and values (which have their place,) to get to the heart of the matter, people setting their sights on the right prize, the right standard, and believing they can reach it.

Strategy

Strategy is about choices – particularly if you want to lead through a point of inflection. Be clear where you’re going to be superior, parity, strong, or good enough, knowing that trying to be best at everything is a recipe for disaster because no one can afford to resource that.

Tactics

Strategy is useless without tactical execution. The strongest organizations have what Jorge Pedraza called “tactical capacity” – “A team’s ability to work under difficult, challenging conditions and to translate strategies into tactical actions decisively, rapidly, and effectively.”

Hard Work

You know who’s doing the work and who’s not. Experienced leaders #1 regret is not moving fast enough on people. When they finally did, others asked, “What took you so long?” This is because what high performers most want is for someone to get the low performers out of their way. Those not doing the work aren’t just hurting themselves. They’re hurting the team.

Discipline

Discipline is about consequences and, in particular, the balance of consequences. Make sure you’re holding people to account and not rewarding undesirable behavior. If you walk by the little things, they grow and people take more and more liberties. The discipline of excellence is not a some-time thing. It’s an all the time thing. You won’t win every time. But you don’t have to beat yourselves.

Click here for a list of my Forbes articles (of which this is #687) and a summary of my book on executive onboarding: The New Leader’s 100-Day Action Plan.

Read More Articles

A group of professionals collaborating.
Everything Communicates: Especially As and To an Executive Onboarding into a New Role

Everything communicates. Everything you say and don’t say, do and don’t do, and the order in which you say and do it sends a message. The same is true for everyone around you. As an executive onboarding into a…

Read Article
Group team working in a office.
Designing The Right Offsites for Different Leadership Levels

Offsites can be rocket fuel or expensive theater. One difference is whether you design each for the kind of leadership each level needs to provide: cultural, strategic, operational, or tactical. When you nest your offsites to fit those roles, you…

Read Article
Argentina flag with the body shape of the country in soccer field.
Strategic Adaptation in Leadership: Lessons from the Argentina–England World Cup Semi-Final

The Argentina–England World Cup semi-final was not just a game; it was a live case study in how leaders deploy strategy and tactics—and what happens when they fail to adjust…

Read Article
Confident executive standing on a modern stage, delivering a presentation
Act Like You’re Already Successful to Jump-Start Success

Success doesn’t start when you “make it.” It starts when you behave like you already have. The best leaders - whether they are taking on a new CEO role, launching…

Read Article
Picture of the Allies Normandy World War II amphibious assault D‑Day
Why Leaders Get the Followers and Decisions They Deserve

Leaders don’t simply get the followers they deserve; they get the decisions they design for. When leaders understand the different ways people create value - artistically, scientifically, and interpersonally -…

Read Article
Primegenesis Operational Leadership
The Underappreciated Power of Operational Leadership

Operational leadership is the undervalued fulcrum between theory and reality. It is where strategy stops living in slide decks, where culture becomes observable behavior, and where tactics gain the coherence…

Read Article