How To Move From Win-Lose To Collaborative Leadership

[et_pb_section fb_built=”1″ admin_label=”section” _builder_version=”3.22″][et_pb_row admin_label=”row” _builder_version=”3.25″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”][et_pb_column type=”4_4″ _builder_version=”3.25″ custom_padding=”|||” custom_padding__hover=”|||”][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.27.4″ module_alignment=”left”]

Trump caved on the wall. Pelosi won. What next? She can certainly push her advantage. Or she could seek ways to collaborate. Her choice probably depends on her objectives for her working relationship with Trump – which is most likely for that relationship to end.

If she wants to push her advantage, this is the time to drive the programs and inquiries she most cares about. Trump and his colleagues are on the back foot and can be weakened even further on the road to decimation by increased pressure now.

If, on the other hand, she wants to establish a more productive working relationship between the legislative and executive branches, this is the moment to do that. Instead of pushing her advantage to hurt Trump and his colleagues, she could de-escalate the conflict, put aside their personal differences and refocus both their efforts on doing the best they can for the people of the United States.

 

The most likely case is that she’ll push her advantage. But you may make different choices when it comes to your leadership and your colleagues.

A Dollar Bill Analogy

Hold up a dollar bill so you’re looking at the side with the pyramid and the eagle and the other person is looking at the other side.

US Dollar Bill

 GETTY

Ask them what they see in the middle. They will likely answer, “George Washington,” or “A man,” or some variation on the theme.

Tell them they are wrong.

Tell them it’s the word “ONE.”

Tell them they are stupid.

Ask them what’s wrong with them.

Expect them to feel at least uncomfortable and probably a little angry.

Once you’ve stirred up their emotion, turn the bill around so they can see the side you’re looking at and explain that you’ve been looking at different sides of the same piece of paper.

US Dollar Bill

 GETTY

People in our government are digging in on what they see, from their perspective, with their biases. Instead of asking others to explain what they see on the other side of the piece of paper or aisle, they resort to insulting each other.

Choosing Relationships Over Being Right

If it’s more important to prove you’re right, you’ll dig in. You’ll pull in the evidence. You’ll follow Cicero’s advice, “When you have no basis for an argument, abuse the plaintiff.” If you value being right more than you value the relationship, you may or may not win the argument, but you’ll certainly hurt the relationship.

If you value the relationship more, you’ll seek to understand others’ perspectives and look for common ground.

One British union negotiator in the 1970s started every session by getting the different parties to agree on something. Sometimes they could agree on what they were trying to accomplish. Sometimes it was a little more removed. But, even if he had to go all the way back to agreeing that everyone in the room had a mother, he wanted to start with an agreement and then build off of that.

The Road to Collaborative Leadership

Win-lose deals cannot last. People who see themselves as the losers in a relationship will either fight back to become winners or exit the relationship at some point to find another situation in which they can win.

This is why pushing your advantage after a win has to have a detrimental impact on your relationship and ability to work with the loser over time.

This is why the better approach is to follow a win by turning your attention to finding a way for the loser to win the next time. Note this doesn’t mean that you have to lose. Look for win-win opportunities.

That’s the key to collaborative leadership. The relationship has to be good for all over time. Pelosi likely won’t get there because she does not want to have a relationship with Trump over time. She wants him to go away.

When it comes to the people you work with (and live with,) you do need to build relationships over time. The only way that works is that if the relationships are good for all.

[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column][/et_pb_row][/et_pb_section]

Read More Articles

A large crowd of people seated closely together, viewed from behind, attending an event or presentation in a dimly lit venue.
The Stakeholders You’re Not Thinking About – And Why They Can Derail Your First 100 Days

Cracker Barrel made headlines when its relatively new CEO departed after less than two years in the role they were hired to transform. The reasons were complex, but one thread…

Read Article
A person holding a clipboard with a blank sheet of paper and a pen poised to write
Outcome-Based Governance: Aligning Policies, Guidelines, and Principles

Policies channel compliance. Guidelines invite contribution. Principles earn commitment. Start with how you want people to behave at work and then design your governance stack to reinforce, not inhibit that.  Three…

Read Article
Concept image of human brain made of blue and gray paint brushes
The Neuroscience of Leadership: Accelerating Growth Mindset and Enterprise Performance

Organizations’ futures depend less on what their people know today than on how fast they can learn, adapt, and execute tomorrow. Building on Carol Dweck’s Growth Mindset – the idea that abilities can be…

Read Article
A group of professionals collaborating.
Everything Communicates: Especially As and To an Executive Onboarding into a New Role

Everything communicates. Everything you say and don’t say, do and don’t do, and the order in which you say and do it sends a message. The same is true for everyone around you. As an executive onboarding into a…

Read Article
Group team working in a office.
Designing The Right Offsites for Different Leadership Levels

Offsites can be rocket fuel or expensive theater. One difference is whether you design each for the kind of leadership each level needs to provide: cultural, strategic, operational, or tactical. When you nest your offsites to fit those roles, you…

Read Article
Argentina flag with the body shape of the country in soccer field.
Strategic Adaptation in Leadership: Lessons from the Argentina–England World Cup Semi-Final

The Argentina–England World Cup semi-final was not just a game; it was a live case study in how leaders deploy strategy and tactics—and what happens when they fail to adjust…

Read Article