Qualcomm Vs. Microsoft: Take Second Prize Or Hold Out For First Prize?

The announcement that Steve Mollenkopf has been elected CEO of Qualcomm takes him off the short-list of candidates for Microsoft CEO. Or does it? What would you do if you were Mollenkopf? Qualcomm’s board? Microsoft’s board?

20-nanometer NAND flash chip

IntelFreePress

In this particular case, Mollenkopf has been at Qualcomm for twenty years, rising to chief operating officer. It makes all the sense in the world for Mollenkopf to succeed Paul Jacobs as CEO. It also makes sense for Qualcomm to accelerate that transition at this point to take Mollenkopf off the table for the Microsoft job. Qualcomm has been to this movie before, losing COO Sanjay Jha to Motorola and misfiring with their next COO Len Lauer who ended up at Memjet. They know the risks of holding a rising executive back too long.

Conversely, Microsoft weakens its position every day it delays in naming a new CEO. The upside of announcing a new CEO earlier than expected like Qualcomm did is that you can control the dialogue. The downside of delaying, like Microsoft is doing is that you lose control of the dialogue. You lose control with your current employees for whom the stress of not knowing increases ever day. You lose control with potential candidates who get taken off the table by others. You lose control with customers, suppliers, shareholders, and, eventually, everyone that matters.

We can only imagine what’s going through Mollenkopf’s mind. There’s no doubt that he’s pleased with his own progress at Qualcomm and thrilled to be named to the top job. Nice to be in the running for Microsoft too.

What’s the right approach for you?

Should you accelerate promotions to reduce the risk of losing your top people? Maybe. It’s certainly a better approach than waiting until they’ve been offered another job and trying to “save” them. That rarely works. Organizations tend to look at people differently once they’ve proved themselves to be traitors. Even if they stay, they have a hard time recovering from the emotional hit. On the other hand, accelerating promotions sends a pre-emptive message of confidence and may inspire people even more.

Should you accept your second choice job or hold out for the possibility of the perfect job? There’s no right answer here. The “How stupid would you feel?” question can help. How stupid would you feel if you took your second choice job and found out later you were going to be offered first choice? How stupid would you feel if you turned down second choice and then did not get your first choice? Make your choice. Write it down. Sleep on it. You’ll know in the morning.

Read More Articles

Professional reviewing charts and financial reports at a meeting table, writing notes on documents with graphs, data visuals, and sticky notes.
A Good Acquisition Story Is Not a Plan.

When Wolf-Gordon announced it was buying Andor Willow and Look Walls and Interiors, the logic behind the acquisition was easy to read. The private equity owner, Charger Investment Partners, wants…

Read Article
Three Leadership Questions to Answer Before Green-lighting a Project

Many tactical projects fail before they start because leaders green-light the wrong things for the wrong reasons. Before you say “yes,” to a project, you and your team should answer…

Read Article
Two martial man engaging in a judo combat
Deploying Judo Strategy To Throw A Stronger Business Competitor

In judo, you do not try to overpower a stronger opponent. You accept their strength, side-step their thrust, and use their weight and momentum to throw them. My earlier article,…

Read Article
A rugged expedition vehicle drives along a long, empty road toward lush mountains under a dramatic sky.
Deliberately Stupid Executive Onboarding

Every executive walking into a new role is, for a while, stupid. Not incapable. Not unqualified. Stupid in the specific, unavoidable sense that they do not yet know what they…

Read Article
A group of executives in a meeting, getting to know each other and working together.
Succeeding Your Own Boss

There's a version of executive onboarding that almost never gets written about, probably because it looks so easy from the outside. Whether it’s the CFO succeeding the CEO, or the…

Read Article
Functional Leader Onboarding: Converge Before You Evolve

The fastest way for a new functional or operational leader to fail is to start changing the team before becoming part of it. The better sequence is simpler and harder: converge first,…

Read Article