Compliments And Criticism – Why And How To Encourage More

[et_pb_section fb_built=”1″ _builder_version=”3.22″][et_pb_row _builder_version=”3.25″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”][et_pb_column type=”4_4″ _builder_version=”3.25″ custom_padding=”|||” custom_padding__hover=”|||”][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.27.4″ link_option_url=”https://www.forbes.com/sites/georgebradt/2019/06/04/get-an-early-read-on-how-your-new-boss-manages/#72c0033a4056″ link_option_url_new_window=”on”]

Everything communicates – everything you are, do and say, to what you pay attention, and the way you react to others. Receive compliments in a way that impacts how others perceive themselves – essentially by saying, “Thank you” with your words and actions. React to bad news about yourself or others by appreciating it in a way that encourages those messengers to give you more of it in the prompt, straightforward and unvarnished way you want it delivered.

Receiving Compliments

Long ago in a galaxy far away someone suggested the best way to respond to a compliment was by saying “Thank you.” He urged us to accept compliments as the fully formed gifts they are meant to be. There is no need to build on them, defer them, or deny them.

Last year someone complimented me on something I wrote. I replied, “I’m not sure it was that good.” She jumped all over me, saying “Don’t ever say that again. It makes aspiring writers lose faith in themselves.”

Receiving Bad News

A woman walked into my office unannounced, closed the door, and sat down. She was visibly upset. So, I waited. She told me about something someone else was doing that made it hard for her to do her job. My immediate thought was about how to make this lady glad she had shared this with me by the time she left my office. I probed for understanding and then suggested a plan of action that I could take to correct the situation without letting anyone know she’d said anything to me. She left pleased. The plan worked.

One man asked for some honest feedback in a meeting. One of his subordinates gave it to him. The boss said nothing in the meeting. But, as soon as the meeting was over, he called the subordinate into his office and berated him about a completely different subject. The subordinate suggested the boss was mad about his feedback in the meeting. The boss, of course, insisted the two things were completely unrelated.

BRAVE approach to receiving news

The BRAVE questions can guide your response to good and bad news.

Environment – Where to play

Sometimes you can choose the physical location in which you’re going to receive news. If you can, choose a place that is safe and conducive to a conversation. If you have to react to news on the spot, you can still choose your emotional state. You can’t control events. But you can control your reaction to events.

Values – What matters and why

Your first thought should be to consider what matters and why to the person giving you the news. Then think about the impact you want to have on them and the effect you want that impact to have. I did this well in the example above of the person giving me bad news. And I did this poorly in the example of the person paying me a compliment. Consider how you want them to feel.

Attitude – How to win

With the win defined as how you want the person delivering the news to feel, you’re ready to make choices to guide what you do and say. Pause for a moment to think before you talk. The pause itself communicates that you’re thinking about what they said.

Relationships – How to connect

Now you’re ready to react and say the words that make them feel the way you want them to feel.

Behaviors – What impact

Words are just the first step. You have to put your words into action. Do what you promise to do to help them. Make the changes in your own behaviors they suggest. Then thank them for their feedback – whether it was positive or negative.

For bonus points, check back with them later. Reinforce how valuable you found their feedback or suggestions – the impact they made. Tell them what you’ve done with their gift – the effect of that impact. Invite them to give you more news going forward – good and bad.

Click here for a list of my Forbes articles and a summary of my book on executive onboarding: The New Leader’s 100-Day Action Plan.

[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column][/et_pb_row][/et_pb_section]

Read More Articles

Functional Leader Onboarding: Converge Before You Evolve

The fastest way for a new functional or operational leader to fail is to start changing the team before becoming part of it. The better sequence is simpler and harder: converge first,…

Read Article
Group of executives planning strategies in a office.
Integration Leadership Isn’t a Detail. It’s the Deal.

KKR's $5.7 billion agreement to acquire Integer Holdings closed a strategic review that started back in April. The medtech manufacturer's board ran the process. Advisors ran the numbers. Lawyers ran…

Read Article
In M&A Integration, Culture Isn’t the Soft Part. It’s the Job.

Private equity has been on a buying spree. Bolt-on acquisitions, platform builds, roll-ups across logistics, healthcare, professional services, and beyond. Deal teams have gotten faster and more disciplined about diligence,…

Read Article
The First 100 Days Don’t Start on Day One. They Start Now.

When Infosys named Ashiss Kumar Dash as CEO-designate in July 2026, the announcement came alongside news that the company had lost a major European client - one of several large…

Read Article
A large crowd of people seated closely together, viewed from behind, attending an event or presentation in a dimly lit venue.
The Stakeholders You’re Not Thinking About – And Why They Can Derail Your First 100 Days

Cracker Barrel made headlines when its relatively new CEO departed after less than two years in the role they were hired to transform. The reasons were complex, but one thread…

Read Article
A person holding a clipboard with a blank sheet of paper and a pen poised to write
Outcome-Based Governance: Aligning Policies, Guidelines, and Principles

Policies channel compliance. Guidelines invite contribution. Principles earn commitment. Start with how you want people to behave at work and then design your governance stack to reinforce, not inhibit that.  Three…

Read Article