How to Turn Rejection into a Job Offer

Most often, a job search rejection is an emphatic “No.” But sometimes, “no” can mean “not now” or “I’m not sure yet.” How you handle rejection can make the difference in turning  “no” into an offer. The key is to react in such a way that gives the person rejecting you a reason to re-think their position.

walking out the door – Photo credit: woodleywonderworks

At the end of an interview for a sales position fresh out of college, the hiring manager told me, “Unfortunately, we don’t have any needs right now.” I responded: “You will at some point. And when you do, you know where to find me.” I was hired two weeks later.

Alan Carniol, founder of Interview Success Formula, shared a story with me from the other side of the table. He needed web marketing support and was looking for part-time help. The choices came down to an outside agency and Juan. He chose the outside agency to give him greater flexibility. But when the agency couldn’t start immediately, he had Juan fill in on an interim basis.

When the agency was ready, he nicely told Juan goodbye. As Carniol related to me:

Juan was disappointed and suggested that if things didn’t work out with the agency that I could begin working with him again. I offered one better, suggesting he spend a few hours that month reviewing the work of this new agency to make sure they were on track, and to keep me posted. 

Three days into working with this new agency, it was obvious their work was not up to standard. So when Juan emailed to ask how it was going, my response was pretty clear…

Carniol hired Juan.

There are a couple of lessons here.

For the hiring manager:

  • Keep your options open by treating everyone with respect and fairness, and letting them know what you’re doing, what you’re thinking and why.
  • Leverage interim resources to keep you from jumping to the wrong choice just because it’s more convenient. This way you can take your time, think things through, create more options and have a lot more confidence in your final decision.
  • Manage transitions with care, making sure not to burn bridges you don’t need to burn. This is particularly applicable to people to whom you are rejecting. You never know when your first choice won’t work out, or when circumstances will change and you need to activate more than one of your options.

For the candidate:

  • Do great work all the time – in permanent and interim roles. Even if the permanent role ends, you never know when you’re going to bump into people you worked with or for again. You also never know when they’ll recommend you to others. Interim roles are often really extended interviews. Bring your “A” game every day.
  • Manage rejections with care, making it as easy as possible for people to change their minds. Make them sorry to see you go. Make them think “what a great person” and give them an excuse to keep in contact with you, contact you again, or for you to contact them. Keep in touch, respectfully, so that when things change (and they will), you’re top of mind.
  • Invest in your own onboarding to keep yourself from being part of the 40% that fail in a new job.

This is a good example of step 1 of The New Leader’s Playbook:  Position Yourself for Success

There are several components of this including positioning yourself for a leadership role, selling before you buy, mapping and avoiding the most common land mines, uncovering hidden risks in the organization, role, and fit, and choosing the right approach for your transition type.  (Including an interim role.)

Read More Articles

The Benefit of Front Foot Executive Onboarding

Don’t lay back. Some executives let someone else manage their onboarding into a new role. This increases their chances of falling into the 40% of new leaders that get fired,…

Read Article
Nvidia logo with a black background
What Colette Kress Must Do As Nvidia’s Interim CEO

Nvidia's board has named CFO Colette Kress interim CEO following Jensen Huang's resignation, effective immediately. She keeps the CFO job too. The board is searching for a permanent CEO, inside…

Read Article
Professionals shaking hands in a bright office during a meeting, symbolizing partnership.
Your First 100 Days Are a Trust Test. Here’s How to Pass It

Executives rarely start new roles with real trust. Before day one, most organizations hold new leaders at arm’s‑length, relying on resumes, references, and search‑firm vetting instead of firsthand experience. The…

Read Article
Alt text (100 characters): Speedboat cutting across deep blue water, leaving white wakes behind in an aerial ocean view.
One Measure Of The Strength Of A Leader Is The Debris They Leave In Their Wake

Every leader leaves a wake. Most spend their time looking at where they’re going. The better question is what they’re leaving behind. Self-centered leaders move up. They hit their numbers,…

Read Article
Book cover titled A Heartbeat Away with a red heartbeat line on a dark background from Dr. Ron Bogart.
Build Nested Leadership That Works Without You

What happens to the organization when you’re not in it?  That question drives Ron Bogart’s leadership fable, A Heartbeat Away: How Strong Organizations Outlast Strong Personalities. One character wakes from…

Read Article
Professional reviewing charts and financial reports at a meeting table, writing notes on documents with graphs, data visuals, and sticky notes.
A Good Acquisition Story Is Not a Plan.

When Wolf-Gordon announced it was buying Andor Willow and Look Walls and Interiors, the logic behind the acquisition was easy to read. The private equity owner, Charger Investment Partners, wants…

Read Article