Onboarding the New CEO

John Pepper and Durk Jager were each lifetime Procter & Gamble employees when they became CEO.  Why then did John go on to be one of P&G's best loved, most successful CEOs and Durk get fired after 17 months?

Three keys to success:

  • Pick the right person
  • Manage the steps
  • Re-balance the team

Pick the right person

This about matching the individual to the context and culture as described in my previous post.  The right person has to be right not just for the business context, but also for where the culture is and needs to go in terms of Behaviors, Relationships, Attitudes, Values, and the work Environment.

Both John and Durk were well suited for the business context.  John's attitude and values allowed him to build and maintain more productive relationships than Durk was able to.

Manage the steps

Five Steps:

  1. Create options for new CEOs (like GE's most recent three-way race and the current J&J race)
  2. Decide who will be the new CEO
  3. Announce the new CEO
  4. Transfer power to the new CEO at a specific point in time
  5. Support the new CEO in his or her efforts

P&G generally does as good a job as any in managing these steps.  In Durk's case, the board found it was unable to keep supporting him.

Re-balance the team

The naming of a new CEO throws the leadership team off-balance even if the new CEO is promoted from within.

Presume not that I am the thing I was; For God doth know, so shall the world perceive, That I have turn'd away my former self. – Shakespeare Henry IV, Act V, scene v

Though not quite a new king, a new CEO immediately becomes different than he or she was.  And his or her relationships with everyone need to be reset.  Given this, people are scared.  They want to know where they stand with the new CEO.  Are they in or out?  The sooner the new CEO can make decisions about who he or she is turning away and who he or she is keeping, the sooner the team can get back into balance.

John's leadership team got back in balance very quickly.  Durk's never did.

Your thoughts?

Read More Articles

The Benefit of Front Foot Executive Onboarding

Don’t lay back. Some executives let someone else manage their onboarding into a new role. This increases their chances of falling into the 40% of new leaders that get fired,…

Read Article
Nvidia logo with a black background
What Colette Kress Must Do As Nvidia’s Interim CEO

Nvidia's board has named CFO Colette Kress interim CEO following Jensen Huang's resignation, effective immediately. She keeps the CFO job too. The board is searching for a permanent CEO, inside…

Read Article
Professionals shaking hands in a bright office during a meeting, symbolizing partnership.
Your First 100 Days Are a Trust Test. Here’s How to Pass It

Executives rarely start new roles with real trust. Before day one, most organizations hold new leaders at arm’s‑length, relying on resumes, references, and search‑firm vetting instead of firsthand experience. The…

Read Article
Alt text (100 characters): Speedboat cutting across deep blue water, leaving white wakes behind in an aerial ocean view.
One Measure Of The Strength Of A Leader Is The Debris They Leave In Their Wake

Every leader leaves a wake. Most spend their time looking at where they’re going. The better question is what they’re leaving behind. Self-centered leaders move up. They hit their numbers,…

Read Article
Book cover titled A Heartbeat Away with a red heartbeat line on a dark background from Dr. Ron Bogart.
Build Nested Leadership That Works Without You

What happens to the organization when you’re not in it?  That question drives Ron Bogart’s leadership fable, A Heartbeat Away: How Strong Organizations Outlast Strong Personalities. One character wakes from…

Read Article
Professional reviewing charts and financial reports at a meeting table, writing notes on documents with graphs, data visuals, and sticky notes.
A Good Acquisition Story Is Not a Plan.

When Wolf-Gordon announced it was buying Andor Willow and Look Walls and Interiors, the logic behind the acquisition was easy to read. The private equity owner, Charger Investment Partners, wants…

Read Article